After the top 8 belted out ’80s hits on Wednesday night’s American Idol, it was tough to predict — by the judges’ comments — who would be going home Thursday, but America once again voted another contestant off the competition.

Source: http://www.ivillage.com/american-idol-results-who-was-eliminated-after-80s-night/1-a-442109?dst=iv%3AiVillage%3Aamerican-idol-results-who-was-eliminated-after-80s-night-442109

January Jones Jennie Finch Jennifer Aniston Jennifer Gareis Jennifer Garner Jennifer Gimenez Jennifer Love Hewitt Jennifer Morrison Jennifer ODell Jennifer Scholle